Out of Ireland, into India

Reflections on an East/West life

Followers

When Yash decided to marry me all those years ago, he was aware of the fact that he was going against a very strong tradition of the culture of his community. I am talking about arranged marriage. Arranged marriages were and still are very much the norm in eastern cultures. Things are slowly changing and nowadays, many of the marriages we attend are in fact ‘love marriages’ as they have come to be called. Well, as Yash sometimes says, in a lighthearted manner, ‘all marriages are love marriages in the beginning. Then they turn into hate marriages'. I just say ‘speak for yourself!’.

People in the modern world generally have a concept of marriage as having something to do with romantic love, but that is only a modern concept. Marriage is something which is practical and which needs a practical basis. As far as I can see, it is only in the last century or so that people have been having marriages which are based on the concept of romantic love. In Ireland, where I come from, the matchmaker was a very important person in society. This was the case, especially in rural areas, up to about half a century ago.

It’s fairly obvious that parents would like their daughters to marry someone of the same social class. And preferably someone with a good income. East or west, all parents have the same dreams for their children. As society has advanced, women and young people have gained more personal freedom. This is why people are finding their own partners as opposed to waiting for their parents to find someone for them. Many social barriers have also broken down, giving people the chance to meet and form relationships independent of parental involvement. This is the reason, in my opinion, why the west has practically discarded the concept of arranged marriages. Indeed, some people never marry at all, but prefer to live together. It’s all about personal choice and individual circumstances.

When Yash was young (he’s fifty now) there was little or no co-education. There were very few working girls too. So his opportunities to meet girls were severely limited. His parents actually found a girl from their community and decided to get Yash married to her. But just before they could finalise things, Yash announced that he was going to Europe for a two year period, for research regarding a concept on which he was working. He was a research scientist in those days. There was no time for them to organise the wedding and get the girl’s passport arranged so that she could accompany him. His parents pleaded with him to postpone his plans, but Yash explained that he could lose the sponsorship if he delayed. The girl’s family was very anxious to have Yash as their son in law as he is a highly qualified man with a good job. So they suggested a long engagement, meaning that the couple should get engaged and marry immediately on Yash’s return. Yash would have none of this. He did not want to go abroad with the responsibility of an unknown fiancée to add to his tensions. He felt that if he was going to have an arranged marriage, the engagement period should be as short as possible. How right he was, in retrospect!

So what did his parents do? They tried a little manipulation. On Yash’s journey to Delhi from our city in north India to catch his flight, his parents suggested that their farewell party drop in to the house of some friends in a town on the way for some refreshment. Yash didn’t know these friends and was a little puzzled at their insistence. But things soon became clear. The house was freshly painted. And decorated. And the daughter of these friends was lavishly dressed in a silk sari, dripping with gold jewellery …..and (skillfully) plastered with make up. Yash took in the whole scene and felt sick at heart. He wanted to just run away. Having seen his own sisters dressed up and displayed to prospective suitors from time to time, he understood the hurt and bewilderment that young girls feel when someone says no. How could he tell this girl that it was nothing personal, he thought she was lovely, but it just wasn’t the right time for him to make a marriage decision? Would it make her feel any better, or would it just add to the bitterness of rejection? And his parents! He was furious with them. In his opinion, he felt that they had just used the worst form of emotional blackmail. They knew how much Yash hates hurting anyone.

Well, Yash hardened his heart and said no. He let his parents deal with the embarrassing technicalities. It was their problem, let them deal with it. The trouble was, when he tried to tell them that it was nothing personal, not the right time, they kept saying ‘oh, don’t worry, the time will pass ‘. So shock treatment became necessary. ‘I don’t find the girl attractive enough! She’s too plain!’ He said. That did it! He was off the hook.

I don’t think Yash has ever really forgiven himself for this. In fact when we first became friends in Dublin all those years ago, and started discussing our personal matters with each other, this was one of the first things he discussed with me. He felt guilty about upsetting the girl, even more than he did about disappointing his parents.

The story does have a happy ending. The girl’s parents found her the perfect match even before Yash returned to India……..by then he was in love with me, but that’s another story! She remains happy, living near her parents and I believe she is now the mother of two grown up children.

We know about her fate because she is distantly related to the family of my mother in law. I only came to know this a few years later. One day, when Neil and Mel were small (the last two hadn’t yet made their appearance) and Yash was at work, we were visited by a distant relative. She was a nice looking woman about thirty three, the same age as me at that time, and had decided to visit our home as she was passing through our city. My in-laws welcomed her with great respect and warmth. Her name was Purnima, I remember. I was not looking my best that day. I was wearing my most disgusting jeans and sweatshirt ensemble. My hair was scraped back in a rubber band and I was running around like a dervish, chasing Neil and Mel, trying to grab them to have a bath.

I noticed her watching me, studying me, almost. But not unkindly. I saw her smile gently to herself. ‘So this is Yash’s wife!’ I heard her say, to no one in particular. I wondered who she was. I felt a bit self-conscious considering my dishevelled appearance and ‘frazzled mum’ mode. It was only after she left I came to know her identity. She was in fact the sister of the girl Yash had rejected as being ‘too plain’. Now this girl would come to know know, that Yash’s wife was hardly an improvement on plain. In fact, Yash’s wife, that day looked like a complete fright! Oh duh!!!!

But! If it made her feel better, I’m not sorry. She deserves some compensation for what she probably suffered that day. Needless to say, I never mentioned this to Yash!!!!

25 comments:

what an amazing story! dropped in from SITS.

That is a very nice story, thank you for sharing that.

Anne

But the bottom line is You and Yash are happy living together with two kids. Maybe the girl and her sister has still bitterness in their hearts that's why they mocked you like that. And what does she mean by "too plain", I am also plain looking and I found it beautiful. What does she expect for you to be. . . overdecorated?

LOL, well this is getting longer. Everyone is really meant for someone. We may not know the person, we may have not seen the person. But I'm sure that someone will come to us, in places we least expect.

AL

Well anybody will feel bad being rejected ..but good thing about arranged marriages is that most of boys /girls get married ..and get a parter for life ..not evryone is lucky enough to find a partner for themselves

Beautiful and so entertaining post! Loved every word of it. Thank you for this insight into the history (and reality) of arranged marriages. In fact, interestingly enough, in our university magazine recently a book was reviewed and advertised, that dealt with the concept of romantic love. Just as you say, it is a term that has come about very recently. Even my grandparents parents very still in arranged marriages.
Your life and decision to move to India sounds so intriguing to me.
Have a wonderful Friday.:)
xoxo

Life works in funny ways, all coming together for a reason far beyond us. Your generosity of spirit is a gift, as is your held tongue... :)))

Great story. I love your blog..you write beautifully x

I'm absolutely certain you didn't look plain that day, but what a strange encounter for both of you. Both you and your husband come across as warm, considerate people who would do their best to avoid hurting someone else's feelings.

Nobody looks their very best when they are at home looking after children, no matter where they live, so I wouldn't worry too much.

My grandmother had an arranged marriage back in the early 1900's. My grandmother and my grandfather both came from a place called Clonaslee in Co Laois. Prior to her marriage, she came to Dublin to be 'In Service' (like Peg), so its not that long ago Ireland was the same!!

Take Care from Sunny Donabate

A lovely post, very nicely written. Thanks for writing about something like this, it is so interesting to hear about a subject like arranged marriage from someone who knows and understands the culture.

And, noone looks good when looking after small kids... you should see the state I'm in right now! x

ps - would you be interested in contributing to the expatmumsblog site? Let me know as I'd love to be able to post this post there too. Thanks, Emily.

You have a full novel in that short post. Fabulous.

Good thing this story had a (somewhat) happy ending!

Sometimes, though, I wish my family believed in arranged marriages. Would take the pressure off of me to find a man!

What a fascinating story, and as you say, with a happy ending. I'm so pleased I came over to visit you - and thank you for visiting me. M xx

I really enjoyed this post! You are right all parents want the best for their children, one fact that binds east and west. Poor Yash, emotionally blackmail is the worst kind, it stays with you. I'm glad your story had a happy ending. I can just hear the sister's chattering about you...

Also, this is perfect for expatmumsblog, do you mind if I post it there?

How thoughtful of Yash to worry about how the girl must be feeling when he must himself have been feeling dreadful.

I reckon you got a good one there,

GG

What a great story! It wouldn't have been easy to stand up to your family like that :)

lovely post. i love getting insigt into you life. YOU SHOULD WRITE A BOOK!

Really love this post. I love hearing about other cultures and to hear from someone who has experienced it is great. It must have been one of the most momentous decisions in your husband's life.
Thanks for commenting on my blog too x

I"m so glad you found my blog! I loved this story here! So interesting that you are distantly related to the first 'chosen' girl. Your husband sounds like he has a tender heart. Sweet story! :)

I just put this up on ExpatMumsBlog -- I hope you like it! http://www.expatmumsblog.com/2009/07/arranged-marriage-anyone.html

Excellent post, really enjoyed reading. I've tagged you over at mine.

What a great story! This blog is a gem.

My late wife Urmeela was the sister of a very good friend of mine. She and I were quite comfortable in each other's company and decided to get married. At that point of time there was no romantic love involved. We just thought that it would be a good idea, despite well wishers who knew both of us, advising us that it would be a disaster.

We got married and love came later. The marriage lasted forty plus years. What she meant to me, how we got married etc are all part of my blog history if you would care to read them.

So, I do not know what to call my marriage. Love marriage or arranged marriage?

About Me

My Photo
gaelikaa
I am Irish. Fifteen years ago I married Yash, a scientist turned university professor and came to live in India. We have four schoolgoing children, Neil (14), Mel (13), Trisha (8) and Nitin, (6). It is not easy going from West to East, but I'm not complaining!
View my complete profile

Whos.amung.us

Post of the Day Winner-

Post of the Day Winner-
for Lost and Found

The Honest Scrap Award

The Honest Scrap Award
Ayak, Armyblond, SuE & MelRoXx

The MeMe Award

The MeMe Award
Thank you Emily

Your Blog is Fabulous Award

Your Blog is Fabulous Award
Thanks to Ayak, Mel &SuE

The Coolest Blog Award

The Coolest Blog Award
From SuE

Swank Award

Swank Award
Thanks MelRoXx

The Splash Award

The Splash Award
Thanks Mimi

Over the Top Award

Over the Top Award
Thanks Henrietta!

The Sunshine Award

Cake Award

Cake Award
Thanks Clareybabble!

The Bookworm Tag

One Lovely Blog Award

One Lovely Blog Award
Thanks Ayak!